Review found that `apps/desktop/README.md#release-versions` and the
2026-09-16 version-derivation note already specify this convention, and
that three of their requirements were reversed without saying so. The
rules themselves are right; what was wrong was leaving them undocumented
and rejecting one of the forms they prescribe.
A stable base takes `-test.YYYYMMDD.index`, which validation refused
because such a version ranks below its base. That ordering is the point:
the form belongs to a test feed that never serves the production
release. Both READMEs, the older note, and a new note now record which
requirements this change reverses and why.
Three defects the review found, each reproducible:
- `afterPack` compared the bundled runtime against the product version,
which broke installed-update qualification: that flow passes a runtime
whose version was deliberately rewritten. The expected version is now
a parameter the preparer supplies, and `verifyDesktopRuntime` says
"bundled X is not the expected Y" rather than naming Electron.
- Upload could only learn the published version from a shell variable,
conflicting with "release fields come only from the target file". It
reads the completion record packaging wrote, and a mismatch now prints
the version that record holds.
- Automatic numbering read one listing page and one fixed directory. It
now follows every page, discards a listing it could not finish rather
than reusing an index that would overwrite a published installer,
bounds the request through the client's own timeout, and reads the
directory an unsigned build actually writes.
Also: `npm run` and `yarn run` set `npm_execpath` too, so the pnpm
resolution checks the path names pnpm; the argument separator can arrive
after a run script's preset arguments, not only first; and the toolchain
probe, parser, build commit, and tarball readers now have specs.
Packaging a build for a test feed or a colleague required bumping the
version in 295 manifests plus the lockfile first, because the version a
build publishes was only ever read from the checkout. Those edits cannot
be committed, so every such build left the working tree dirty, and the
`<version>.<date>.<sequence>` convention behind them lived only in the
operator's memory.
The version a build publishes is now an input. `--release-id` names it,
`--release-id auto` numbers it after the builds already published to the
destination bucket (falling back to local artifacts, since a fresh CI
checkout has none), and it reaches electron-builder through
extraMetadata, the update feed, and the upload validation as one value.
The manifests keep the product version, aligned with the dsh npm
package, and a release still publishes exactly that.
Validation goes through `semver` itself, because `electron-updater`
compares feed versions with `semver.gt` against the installed
`app.getVersion()`: a build version must outrank the product version it
extends, which holds for `0.1.6-alpha.2.20260921.1` over
`0.1.6-alpha.2` and cannot hold on a stable version, where a fourth
release number is not a version at all.
Two things a build could not previously answer for itself:
- Artifacts now carry the commit they were packaged from and whether
that checkout was dirty, so a build handed to a colleague is traceable
without a tag.
- A production upload tags that commit as `desktop-v<version>` once the
artifacts are public, and reports what to run by hand rather than
failing an upload that already completed. Test and local builds are
deliberately left untagged.
A toolchain step now probes tar and the Windows installer compiler
before the first build step, so a host that cannot finish the sequence
says so in seconds rather than minutes.
winewill